
Employers have lots of options when it comes to finding their next nanny or family assistant. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each choice to help you select the one that best suits your needs.
Full-Service Placement Agencies
A quality full-service agency will manage a search from start to finish; handling all the tasks for you. Here’s a rundown of the biggest pros and cons.
Pros
Expert Guidance
Agency owners and staffers have unique insight into the industry, current trends, and your specific market. The nanny industry is highly individualized, nuanced, and lacks standard resources or guidance for employers. This makes expert help in your search extremely valuable.
Professional Candidate Vetting
The nanny industry is completely unregulated (unlike daycares and preschools which must meet standards set by state and federal agencies) and caregivers aren’t overseen by an industry regulatory organization that works to ensure high-quality care (think doctors and the American Medical Association). Nannies do not have to meet minimum requirements for education, experience, skills, or screening. Literally anyone can claim the title of nanny leaving individual employers with the full responsibility of vetting candidates. Working with an agency means they’ll do the important work of ensuring candidates are overall, quality providers before presenting them to you. You should still interview candidates and talk to their references to ensure they’re a good fit for your family.
Time and Energy Savings
Finding the right nanny or family assistant is not a quick or easy process and for many busy parents, having an agency manage all aspects of the search is just a smart use of resources.
A quality full-service placement agency will:
- develop a detailed job description for you, written to attract candidates that best meet your needs
- promote your open position widely through their social media and email lists
- actively recruit candidates for your position
- conduct an in-depth interview with each candidate to expertly evaluate their experience, skill set, employee style, professionalism, and ability to consistently provide high-quality care in a private home
- verify each candidate’s educational accomplishments including degrees and certifications
- conduct detailed phone reference checks with current and former employers and other references
- match you with candidates based on your and the candidate’s specific needs
- present your position to candidates, providing full details about your needs, requirements, family, work environment, and the ideal candidate you’re looking for
- present you a customized, detailed information packet on each candidate so you can make an informed decision around moving forward
- facilitate communication between you and matching candidates including scheduling interviews, assessing continued interest after interviews, supporting contract negotiations, offer letters, onboarding, etc.
Ongoing Support After Hire
Making a good hire is only the first step to success. A long-term, positive relationship with your nanny requires thoughtful onboarding and clear, respectful communication. A quality agency will continue to support you and your employee through all the stages of your employment journey.
Cons
The biggest drawback to using a full-service placement agency is the cost.
Search Fee
Many agencies charge a non-refundable fee to begin your search. This fee doesn’t guarantee they’ll find a nanny for you, only that they’ll make a good faith effort to find a quality match. The search fee can be a few hundred dollars up to several thousand dollars; it all depends on the agency. While most agencies have always charged a deposit, the larger search fee is a recent change in industry practices. It’s a result of agencies investing a lot of hours into a search only to have the employers hire through a DIY avenue.
A search fee is a reasonable ask from an agency, however, before paying a non-refundable fee, make sure the agency at least guarantees to present you with a minimum number of qualified, matching candidates. Many families have paid large search fees only to realize the agency doesn’t have anyone on their roster that meets the family’s needs.
Placement Fee
When you hire through an agency, they’ll charge you a placement fee, either a flat fee based on the role (e.g. nanny, chef) or a percentage of the employee’s annual income or compensation package (wages and the dollar value of benefits). Fees vary greatly by agency. Smaller nanny agencies serving limited markets (e.g. Cleveland) charge less – generally $3,000 to $6,000. Larger private service staffing agencies (e.g. those that place nannies, household managers, chefs) or niche agencies (e.g. those that place specialty nannies like travel or ROTA nannies) serving high-demand markets (e.g. San Francisco, Boston) often charge $8,000 to $20,000 or more per placement. Please note, these are ballpark numbers; make sure you clearly understand the fees associated with a search and placement and the refund / replacement policy before registering with an agency.
To find a quality agency in your area, you can visit the Association of Premier Nanny Agencies. They set standards for agencies across the country and are the best place to start your search for a standout agency that serves your area. I’m also happy to point you in the right direction. Just email me at info@NannyCareHub.com.
Remember, not all agencies are created equal. Be smart when choosing an agency to help you find the person you’ll trust with your child and home.
Top Nanny Talent
Top Nanny Talent is a new service born from my decades of experience working with candidates, employers, and agencies—helping them navigate the challenges of today’s market and search system.
TNT isn’t a traditional agency that manages the entire hiring process, nor is it a job board, hiring platform, or social media group that leaves all the work to employers. Instead, we bridge the gap, providing personal search assistance to help you confidently and successfully navigate the hiring process in a way that fits your specific needs.
Pros
Customized Approach
Each family’s hiring experience is unique, shaped by their individual needs, style, and comfort level with the search process. Top Nanny Talent gives employers the flexibility to choose the level of assistance and guidance that works best for them and access it whenever and however it’s most convenient.
All packages include the essentials for a successful search, but for those who want extra help, TNT offers expanded services with unlimited, personalized one-on-one search assistance. The concierge package offers families the same level of search support as a placement agency minus the vetting of candidates. (That’s where the budget savings come from.)
Budget-Friendly Pricing
Top Nanny Talent costs more than platforms like Care.com or SitterCity.com, however, it costs significantly less than a full-service placement agency. The expertly designed system streamlines and automates essential tasks, allowing us to focus our time and attention on providing personalized, expert guidance and search management.
Broad Search Capacity
Today, quality leads come from a wide variety of sources; word-of-mouth, social media, job boards, online platforms, and neighborhood apps, just to name a few. While TNT actively recruits quality candidates, we know no one source or site can connect with all available candidates so we provide clients with an easy way to funnel candidates from any source through our exclusive candidate database. It allows them to gather detailed information, receive insightful summaries and profiles, and manage all leads in one place.
Expert Guidance
As I said in the agency section, the nanny industry is highly individualized, nuanced, and lacks standard resources or guidance for employers. As a seasoned, trusted consultant for all segments of our field – in-home professionals, employers, and placement agencies – I offer real-world guidance and exclusive tools for every stage of the hiring process and the ongoing employment relationship.
Cons
Employers Must Fully Vet Candidates
While Top Nanny Talent sets minimum qualifications for candidates, we do not guarantee candidates meet those qualifications or are quality caregivers. Employers must invest time into conducting interviews, checking references, and running background checks. We provide expert guidance and tools to help you navigate the process, however, employers are fully responsible for vetting candidates and making the final hiring decision.
Commitment to Quality Employment
Top Nanny Talent requires employers to pay legally, offer a competitive wage, guaranteed hours, paid time off, and mileage reimbursement if the nanny uses their car for work purposes, and provide a safe, respectful work environment. Full disclosure here; I view these requirements as a pro however, some employers feel it’s an overreach.
For more information on the services offered, visit TopNannyTalent.com or schedule a free 30 minute consultation with me today.
Do-It-Yourself Search Avenues
There are a multitude of DIY ways to find candidates in today’s market; social media, job boards, online platforms, neighborhood discussion groups and apps, workplace discussion groups, and on and on. While the DIY search is the most popular hiring avenue in the nanny industry, it also can be the most difficult.
Pros
Free or Low Cost
The biggest advantage of a DIY search is the cost. Options like social media (e.g. Facebook groups), job boards (e.g. Indeed), and neighborhood discussion groups are completely free. Online platforms like Care.com and SitterCity.com are low cost, often less than $50 per month.
Broad Search Capacity
Using multiple DIY search avenues provides the broadest search and by extension, the largest number of leads.
Control
With a DIY search, employers have full control over every aspect of the search and can connect directly with candidates.
Cons
Disjointed Process
Because nothing is standardized, DIY searches are usually all over the map. Tasks overlap or repeat, tracking information can be overwhelming, and accurate evaluations and comparisons are difficult to achieve.
Huge Investment of Time and Energy Required
Because the nanny industry is completely unregulated, DIY search avenues are flooded with unqualified, uncommitted, or unprofessional candidates. (This isn’t a commentary on those candidates as individuals, instead, it speaks to their inability to work successfully in a nanny role and the way they engage in the search process.) A quality job posting can receive hundreds of responses with only a handful having any real potential. Sifting through interested candidates to find quality leads wastes a lot of time and energy, something that’s already in short supply for parents.
Lack of Easily Accessible Expert Guidance
There are a lot of online resources available on hiring a nanny, however, most don’t provide the accurate, in-depth information employers need to effectively navigate the hiring process. This leaves employers with half-answered questions, incorrect information, and forced to use a “hope for the best” approach. When hiring the person you’ll trust with your child’s well-being and safety, that unknowing can be unsettling at best.
Have Additional Questions?
I can help! If you’re considering the nanny or family assistant option or actively hiring, I’d love the opportunity to connect and learn more about your needs. Please email me at info@NannyCareHub.com or schedule a free 30 minute consultation with me today.
- The Nanny/Child Relationship: A NNRW Tribute - September 21, 2026
- Boundary Work Starts Before the Conversation - May 22, 2026
- Please Stop Using “DOE” in Nanny Job Posts - December 12, 2025

